Disclosure: This article contains affiliate links. We may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you if you purchase through our links. Read our full disclosure.

In 2016, the BeautyBlender changed the world. Suddenly, everyone was bouncing a neon pink egg on their face. It promised an "airbrushed" finish that brushes just couldn't replicate.

But at $20 a pop (for a piece of foam that you have to throw away every 3 months), it's expensive.

Good news: In 2026, the dupes have officially caught up. We found sponges for as low as $1.50 that are just as soft, bouncy, and effective as the original.

πŸ“– Table of Contents

Velvet vs. Foam Sponges

Classic Foam: The standard material. It's porous, holding water to create that dewy, sheer finish. It eats up a bit more product but gives the most natural look.

Velvet/Microfiber: These are covered in tiny fuzzy fibers (like a peach). They act like a hybrid between a brush and a sponge. They absorb way less product and give higher coverage.

πŸ“Š Comparison Table: Top 10 Makeup Sponges

Sponge Best For Softness (1-10) Price
Original BeautyBlender The Classic 10/10 $20
AOA Paw Paw Wonder Blender Best Value 9.5/10 $1.55
Real Techniques Miracle Complexion Flat Edge 8/10 $6
Juno & Co. Microfiber Full Coverage 7/10 $6
EcoTools BioBlender Eco-Friendly 8/10 $6
Beakey 5 Pc Set Bulk Buy 7/10 (Firmer) $9 (Set)
Fenty Beauty Precision Under Eyes 9/10 $16
Elf Camo Concealer Sponge Detail Work 8/10 $6
Sonia Kashuk Marble Drugstore 8/10 $7
Morphe Highlight & Contour Chiseled 7/10 $8

Best Makeup Sponges (Detailed Reviews)

1. The Original BeautyBlender β€” The Gold Standard

Best for: Perfectionists.

Why we love it: Despite the dupes, the original patented foam is still unique. It is perfectly porous, incredibly soft, and never leaves texture. If you have the budget, it's still the best.

Pros:

  • Perfect density
  • No latex
  • Flawless finish

Cons: $20 is a lot for a sponge.

Check Price on Amazon

2. AOA Paw Paw Wonder Blender β€” Best Dupe (Shockingly Good)

Best for: Everyone.

Why we love it: This $1.55 sponge broke the internet. It is 98% identical to the BeautyBlender in softness and bounce. You can buy 12 of them for the price of one BB. It's softer than the Real Techniques one.

Pros:

  • Unbeatable Price
  • High quality foam
  • Good shape

Cons: So soft it can tear if washed roughly.

Check Price on Amazon

3. Real Techniques Miracle Complexion Sponge β€” Best Shape

Best for: Contour & Baking.

Why we love it: The flat edge is genius. It allows you to stamp powder under the eyes or carve out a contour line with precision. The foam is slightly denser than BB but very durable.

Pros:

  • Flat edge for cutting
  • Available everywhere
  • Cheap

Cons: Can soak up more foundation.

Check Price on Amazon

4. Juno & Co. Microfiber Velvet Sponge β€” Best for Coverage

Best for: Saving product.

Why we love it: It feels like a peach. The microfiber bristles keep the foundation on the surface rather than sucking it in. You get the coverage of a brush with the finish of a sponge.

Pros:

  • Use 50% less foundation
  • Very soft
  • High coverage

Cons: Can feel a bit "stiff" when dry.

Check Price on Amazon

5. EcoTools BioBlender β€” Best Sustainable

Best for: The environment.

Why we love it: It's the world's first 100% biodegradable makeup sponge. You can literally plant it in your garden when you're done (compostable). It performs just as well as synthetic ones.

Pros:

  • Compostable
  • Plant-based
  • Same RT shape

Cons: Degrades faster (replace monthly).

Check Price on Amazon

6. Beakey 5 Piece Set β€” Best Bulk Option

Best for: Makeup artists/Students.

Why we love it: You get 5 sponges for under $10. They are quite dense/firm, which some people prefer for sheer coverage. They expand hugely when wet.

Pros:

  • Cheap bulk buy
  • Latex free
  • Multi-colored

Cons: Stiffer foam.

Check Price on Amazon

7. Fenty Beauty Precision Makeup Sponge 100 β€” Best for Detail

Best for: Under eyes.

Why we love it: It has a slanted edge, a flat top, and a rounded bottom. The flat top is incredible for getting right into the inner corner of the eye or baking the sides of the nose.

Pros:

  • Unique triple shape
  • Very precise
  • Rihanna approved

Cons: Pricey.

Check Price on Amazon

8. Elf Camo Concealer Sponge β€” Best Small Sponge

Best for: Spot concealing.

Why we love it: This is smaller than a normal sponge. It's designed specifically to pair with the Elf Camo Concealer. It fits perfectly into the undereye area.

Pros:

  • Perfect size for eyes
  • Super soft
  • $6

Cons: Too small for full face.

Check Price on Amazon

9. Sonia Kashuk Marble Sponge β€” Best Drugstore Design

Best for: Looking cute on vanity.

Why we love it: A Target staple. The marble design is chic, and the foam is surprisingly high quality. It's soft, bouncy, and reliable.

Pros:

  • Aesthetics
  • Reliable
  • Accessible

Cons: Stains easily.

Check Price on Amazon

10. Morphe Highlight & Contour Sponge β€” Best Chiseled Edge

Best for: Cream contour.

Why we love it: It has a very sharp edge that is perfect for carving out cheekbones with cream contour. The bottom is rounded for blending.

Pros:

  • Sharp edges
  • Firm density
  • Good for sculpting

Cons: Harder to clean.

Check Price on Amazon

How to Clean Properly

Dirty sponges cause acne. Fact. To clean it deep:

  1. Wet sponge.
  2. Rub it against a bar of soap (plain Dove bar works well).
  3. Squeeze and rinse until water runs clear.
  4. Hack: Microwaving it in a bowl of water boils the bacteria, but watch outβ€”it can melt if you do it too long!

⚠️ You're Using It Dry

A makeup sponge is designed to be used DAMP. Run it under water, squeeze it out until it's just moist. If you use it dry, it will just absorb all your foundation and leave streaks.

βœ… Quick Summary Checklist

  • β˜‘οΈ Best Dupe: AOA Paw Paw ($1.55)
  • β˜‘οΈ Best Shape: Real Techniques Miracle Complexion
  • β˜‘οΈ Highest Coverage: Juno & Co. Microfiber

❓ Frequently Asked Questions

When should I throw it away?

Every 3 months. If it starts crumbling or growing black spots (mold), toss it immediately.

Can I use it for powder?

Yes. A damp sponge pressed into loose powder is the secret to "baking" your undereyes for a crease-free finish.

πŸ”— Related Articles

Final Thoughts

There is absolutely no reason to spend $20 on a sponge anymore. The AOA Paw Paw ($1.55) is virtually indistinguishable from the luxury version. Stock up on those.

✍️

Ivan Dsouza

Beauty editor and skincare researcher at NxtLifestyle. Dedicated to finding scientifically-backed products that actually work.